1958 Gibson J-45 vs 1961 Martin D-18: Battle of the ‘Hogs

Battle of the ‘Hogs;

Which do you choose?

On the left, a 1958 Gibson J-45.

On the right, a 1961 Martin D-18 (with custom pickguards).

In 1958, the J-45 you would’ve run you $149.00. The ‘61 D-18 would’ve been $210.00 (a D-28 a whopping $335!!).

I’ve always fancied myself a Gibson guy, perhaps because I grew up about 20 miles from 225 Parsons Street. I had friends who’s grandparents worked there before they closed. But there’s something about an old D-18…

If you had to chose, which would be your choice?

* it must be stated neither is for sale *